Pizza restaurants

Bellisario Pizza Shop

4.5 160 reviews 4:00 PM - 12:00 AM 1842 Homeville Rd, West Mifflin, PA 15122, United States

Discover this place

Located at 1842 Homeville Rd in West Mifflin, PA, Bellisario Pizza Shop has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts. With an old-school vibe, this quaint pizzeria emanates warmth and charm, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal.

Customer reviews consistently rave about the pizza's impeccable quality. Dovydas describes it as "excellent," epitomizing the classic pizzeria experience. Emperatris Zeiss highlights the expertly balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio and a crust that achieves a delightful crunch without any sogginess. This attention to detail speaks volumes about the owner's commitment to quality.

The menu isn't limited to just pizza; diners also sing praise for the Italian hoagies. Emma Mayfield's enthusiastic endorsement suggests these hoagies are unmatched in flavor, adding to the shop's allure. Toby Wood points out the passionate single chef who manages the kitchen, serving up what many refer to as "fire pizza" and delectable wedges.

While the shop operates on a cash-only basis and is more suited for takeout than sit-down dining, the friendly service and amazing food make Bellisario a hidden gem worth visiting. For anyone in Pittsburgh seeking authentic Italian flavors, Bellisario Pizza Shop is a must-try!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Bellisario Pizza Shop before visiting.

Reviews for Bellisario Pizza Shop

4.5

160 reviews

100%

15%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 160 reviews

Bellisario Pizza Shop is widely praised for its authentic old-school pizzeria atmosphere and consistently high-quality offerings. Customers frequently highlight the perfectly balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio, crispy crust, and generous toppings that appeal even to those discerning about traditional pizza styles. The menu variety, including standout hoagies and calzones, is another commonly noted strength. The shop’s intimate, hardworking kitchen staff and friendly owner contribute to a welcoming experience. While the cash-only policy is mentioned, it does not detract significantly from overall positive impressions. Bellisario is regarded as a hidden gem in West Mifflin, beloved for its dedication to classic flavors and attentive service.

Dovydas

Jul 13, 2025

My first time here. Excellent pizza if you're looking for an old school pizzeria this is your place. The owner is a very nice man. Can't wait to try the hoagie.

Toby Wood

Jul 09, 2025

Dude, absolutely love this place! Always just one guy in the Kitchen working his ass off, absolutely fire pizza, wedges, and hoagies. This place is like a hidden gem. Highly recommend!

Emperatris Zeiss

Jun 27, 2025

This is by far, the best pizza and the best calzone I’ve ever tasted. The cheese to sauce ratio was impeccable. The crust was a perfect bit of crunchy around the crust. There was NOT a single bite of pizza that was soggy - and given the moisture of the cheese and sauce the pizza had, I was floored by how perfectly cooked it was. This place is CASH ONLY and although there is sorting available, it doesn’t seem like the type of place you want to sit down and eat. Not that it’s unwelcoming, it’s just very quaint.

Emma Mayfield

Jun 14, 2025

Absolutely to die for Italian hoagie. Love this place. Owner is so nice. I will no longer order Italian hoagies anywhere else

Tamara OBrien

Jun 02, 2025

The best pizza I’ve eaten in Pittsburgh since I moved here a few years ago. I’m a Chicago girl who’s used to thin crust not that thick crust stuff! Abundance of toppings, quality ingredients, and very friendly service!

Joe Conti

Apr 16, 2025

Might be the best pizza in the south hills. Definitely the best in West Mifflin.

William Ninteau

Apr 03, 2025

BEST pizza and calzone I've had since moving to Pittsburgh. Hands down. He was super busy and still got my food done within 15 minutes. I'd wait as long as I need to for this food. Found our new favorite spot.

Rob Link

Mar 17, 2025

This is the real deal! Pizza was great and the staff was friendly! Don't be afraid to walk into the scary walkway in the, what appears to be, a condemned mall. Bring cash - no credit.